logo
HomeTeachersStudentsAdvertiseSubscribeContact
bar
 
  IN THE CLASSROOM
  COLLEGE & CAREERS
  TOOLS AND RESOURCES
  STUDENT VOICES
  SUBMIT A COMMENT/STORY
 

 

Article summary

Consumers are clamoring for more tools to help them stay connected to online media on the road. The federal government thinks they've got more than enough already.

 

Teachers Article  
______________________________________________________

Information Overload
Auto makers push more media gadgetry into cars. The government asks: Why?

September 2011 | Autos
Bookmark and Share

By JOSEPH B. WHITE
The Wall Street Journal

  • ARTICLE
  • LINKS
  • LESSON

Consumers are clamoring for more tools to help them stay connected to online media on the road. The federal government thinks they've got more than enough already.

"There's absolutely no reason for any person to download their Facebook into the car," U.S. Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood said in an interview. "It's not necessary."

 

Mr. LaHood is pushing to open new fronts in his long-running campaign against the proliferation of technology-driven diversions. In conversations with auto industry executives, Mr. LaHood says he is making it plain he isn't pleased with the trend toward putting more media feeds and gadgetry into the cockpits of new vehicles.

MANAGING THE FLOW

Mr. LaHood and the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration have the power to curb the info-tainment technology built into cars, if they can demonstrate a threat to safety. He is also urging auto executives to free up advertising money to create public-service announcements that remind motorists to stay focused on the road, and not to text and drive.

BMW is the second major car maker, after Subaru, to say yes. It's running a television spot that starts with what appears to be a spoof of overprotective parents, but ends with disturbing images of a mother texting behind the wheel, oblivious to the sport-utility vehicle that is about to broadside her car.

BMW's North American CEO Jim O'Donnell says the company plans to run the spot, and related print and online advertising, through the end of the year.

Still, BMW isn't walking away from the in-car media revolution. Customers are demanding more and more information, Mr. O'Donnell says. BMW's approach is to manage that flow, not cut it off, such as by making brief bursts of information available on displays that are readily visible to drivers.

Other auto makers are trying to devise better ways to manage an increasing flow of information and entertainment, while trying to avoid running afoul of Mr. LaHood and his auto-safety regulators.

General Motors is promoting its youth-targeted Chevrolet Cruze compact with an ad that highlights a Facebook-update feature, delivered by a voice program through the car's Onstar communication system.

A GM spokesman says Onstar's Facebook application, which drivers can use with a push of one button while they keep their eyes on the road, is still in the testing phase. No decision has been made to roll it out broadly.

Mr. LaHood's department aims to finish work by early next year on a new set of guidelines governing the design and operation of in-vehicle communications technology, including studies of whether simply making communication via text or voice "hands free" makes a significant difference in safety.

Some studies have suggested that having a phone conversation is just as distracting to a driver using a headset or an audio system as for someone holding a phone.

SNEAK A PEEK

Anyone who has driven a new car decked out with the latest technology knows it is possible for a driver to get a dizzying amount of information about the vital signs of the car, its location, the types of music available from various sources, who's calling on the phone, or even whether a car is hiding in the blind spot.

At the same time, driving in a modern luxury car—or even a new compact car—can be a passive, dull experience. The cruise control can manage the speed. The transmission shifts itself. The scenery is the same as it was the day before.

Small wonder that even drivers who know better are tempted to sneak a peek at the cellphone or hunt for a song on the iPod.

Mr. LaHood compares the effort to change public attitudes toward distracted driving to the long-running efforts to change attitudes and behavior related to drinking and driving. The Transportation Department's 2012 budget requests about $50 million to expand efforts to ticket people texting while driving, following the example of the "Click It or Ticket" campaigns that helped boost seat-belt use to about 85% in 2010.

Still, Mr. LaHood says he knows what he's up against in the fight against distracted driving. He says, "We know people are hooked on cellphones and texting devices.

 

Cars Coveted in High School, Made New
Boutique auto shops are turning out ultra-customized replicas of Porsches, BMWs and Shelby Cobras for wealthy aficionados Article.

Auto Makers Back Fuel Economy Plan
Nine auto makers have told the White House they will endorse a plan that would push corporate average fuel economy to 54.5 miles a gallon between 2017 and 2025. Article

   

ADDITIONAL READING

From The Wall Street Journal: "Group Tells States: Consider Banning All Phone Use By Drivers"

From Motor Trend magazine: Ford Supports Distracted Driving Ban

WEB RESOURCES

Safe Drivers Act
http://www.govtrack.us/congress/billtext.xpd?bill=h112-2333
 
Ford
www.ford.com

Chrysler
www.chrysler.com
 
U.S. Government Website for Distracted Driving
http://www.distraction.gov

VIDEO

In "Study Finds Cellphone Laws Don't Reduce Accidents," The Wall Street Journal's Joe White reports that bans don't stop people from trying to multi-task. Watch here.

OBJECTIVE
Evaluate the need for technology in automobiles

OVERVIEW
Consumers are clamoring for more tools to help them stay connected to online media on the road. The federal government thinks they've got more than enough already.

STANDARDS
NBEA: communication, information technology; NCEE: competition, role of government, supply and demand; NCSS: culture, power, authority and governance, science, technology and society; NCTE: communication, technology

REVIEW
Read the story "Information Overload" and answer these questions:
 
1) How is BMW educating consumers about the dangers of technology-related diversions while also catering to its customers' desire for more connectivity?

2) Who is Ray LaHood, and how is he trying to reduce distracted driving?

ACTIVITY IDEAS
 
• In July, Ford announced its support of a bill introduced by U.S. Rep. Carolyn McCarthy that would ban the use of hand-held cellphones while driving. Go online and read the bill, called the Safe Drivers Act of 2011. Do you think it's a good bill? Why or why not? What would you change or add? If you were a lawmaker, would you vote for it? If you were the CEO of an auto company, would you support the bill? Why or why not? Discuss as a class.
 
• Chrysler and Ford have spent millions investing in connectivity for their cars. Go online and research Ford's SYNC hands-free connectivity system, and Chrysler's UConnect touch. What do they offer drivers? Are they still considered a distraction—or could they be? How much do SYNC and UConnect cost as options? Do other auto makers offer similar technology—or are they developing this technology—for their vehicles?

• In small groups, brainstorm the types of technology you'd like to have in a car. Would any of these be unsafe while driving? How do your needs differ if you're the driver or a passenger? Discuss as a class.
 
• Use the Internet to research distracted driving (see Web Resources). Are certain age groups more likely to be distracted? Make a chart showing the increase in accidents and fatalities because of distracted driving. Are hands-free telephone calls truly distraction-free, or do they still divert the driver's focus from the road? Discuss as a class.

• Invite a drivers' education teacher and a member of your local police force to speak to the class about distracted driving. Learn what you can do to avoid it, and how much of a problem it is in your community. Will you be changing your habits as a driver, or do you already avoid being distracted? What about your parents? Discuss as a class.

• In small groups, create a public service announcement against distracted driving. Choose an audience: teens or adults. And select a medium: print or video. Send your PSA's to The Classroom Edition for possible inclusion on our website or YouTube page. Print PSA's should be submitted as PFDs and be no larger than 8.5 inches by 11 inches. Videos should be no longer than 3 minutes. For questions, or to submit your PSAs, email student.voices@wsj.com.

ADDITIONAL READING

From The Wall Street Journal: "Group Tells States: Consider Banning All Phone Use By Drivers"

From Motor Trend magazine: Ford Supports Distracted Driving Ban

WEB RESOURCES

Safe Drivers Act
http://www.govtrack.us/congress/billtext.xpd?bill=h112-2333
 
Ford
www.ford.com

Chrysler
www.chrysler.com
 
U.S. Government Website for Distracted Driving
http://www.distraction.gov

VIDEO
In "Study Finds Cellphone Laws Don't Reduce Accidents," The Wall Street Journal's Joe White reports that bans don't stop people from trying to multi-task. Watch here.


To access the Teacher Guide quiz and answers, log in here.